Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

HSA 5200 RU Bouvia vs Superior Court Case Analysis

November 15, 2023

Scenario

Analyze ethical and legal implications of cases involving bioethics. Two examples of highly publicized cases are listed below.

The national discussion concerning decision making for incompetent patients began with the 1976 case of Karen Ann Quinlan. Because she had been left in a persistent vegetative state after two periods of anoxia, her parents sought court authorization to remove her from a ventilator. The New Jersey Supreme Court, in a landmark, unanimous decision, authorized the removal based on Quinlan’s constitutional right of privacy, which the court concluded would be lost unless her parents were given authority to exercise it on her behalf. In the 15 years since Quinlan, courts in almost 20 states have reviewed disputes regarding treatment for incompetent patients. Courts in all these states have recognized the general right of competent people to refuse treatment, and in all but two states have also ultimately found that the U.S. Constitution, state constitution, or common law permits a surrogate to make treatment decisions on behalf of an incompetent person (Annas, 1990).

The case of Nancy Cruzan is essentially identical to that of Karen Ann Quinlan, with one exception: Nancy Cruzan, a young woman in a persistent vegetative state because of a 1983 automobile accident, requires only tube feeding (rather than a ventilator and tube feeding) to continue to survive. Her parents firmly believe she would not want to have tube feeding continued under such circumstances, in part based on her own statement that she would not want to continue to live if she could not be “at least halfway normal.” For this reason, a trial judge authorized her parents to have their daughter’s tube feeding discontinued (Annas, 1990).

Instructions

Select a case for which you are familiar or have an interest that involves medical ethics. Prepare a case analysis using the IRAC method. Your analysis should address the following:

The Issue

Rule

Analysis

Conclusion

Resources

Annas, George J, J.D., M.P.H. (1990). Sounding board: Nancy cruzan and the right to die. The New England Journal of Medicine, 323(10), 670-673.

Case, COURT, HSA, Superior

Share This Post

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Midterm paper 2

Double space is acceptable Midterm II Questions (Due May 20, 2019 at 11:59 PM) Directions: Answer ONE of the questions in a 7-10 page essay, using proper essay structure and technique (identifiable thesis statement, concrete examples, etc.). You MUST cite at least 3 different sources in compiling your answer (lecture

Part 1 Fully define (1) Hazard Vulnerability Analysis and

Part 1 Fully define (1) Hazard Vulnerability Analysis and (2) Emergency Operations Planning. What purpose does each serve within Emergency Management? What are the key elements of both tools? Paper should be a minimum of 400 words. Part 2 Explain the four phases of Emergency Management. Which do you believe to

Compare and contrast your peer’s personality trait to that

Compare and contrast your peer’s personality trait to that of your own. How are they similar? How are they different? Given the trait they chose, their choice of P.R.I.C.E. element, and their selected soft skills, comment on their plan to sell that personality trait. Describe your thoughts on their plan.

Saudi Electronic University Cost Effectiveness of The

An effective policy is one that achieves a specific outcome in terms of the impact that it has on an organization. Healthcare organizations need to understanding the importance of a policy with regard to setting the internal and external direction of the organization. This can only be done by measuring

WU Detail and Dynamic Complexity Discussion

Are you overwhelmed by complexity? If so, you are not alone. Peter Senge notes that people are now able to “create far more information that anyone can absorb,” and he continues to say that the “scale of complexity is without precedent” (2006, p. 69). This “detail” complexity can make managing

Identify the APN you interviewed and summarize the

Identify the APN you interviewed and summarize the interview, which may include (if not in the interview, please address): Describe the organization and setting, population, and colleagues where your interviewee works. Examine regulatory and legal requirements for the state in which you plan to practice/work (and that your interviewee resides,

https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/59876

The Public Health System [WLO: 1] [CLOs: 1, 2, 3, 4] This week’s discussion is on the role of the public health system within the greater view of the U.S. health care system. Prior to beginning work on this discussion forum, please review the United States Public Health 101Links to an

By the end of Unit 3, you will have logged into VMock to

By the end of Unit 3, you will have logged into VMock to first practice a job interview, then you will record and submit the PD 202 – Interview Assignment for Unit 6, also in VMock. Feel free to practice using the software by completing the Elevator Pitch as much

Health & Medical Capital Budgeting at Cleveland Clinic

Respond to each of the following prompts or questions: Using the information provided in the Los Reyes Hospital case study from Module Three, what capital expenditures may the selected departments need to budget? Considering the organization you selected, what is a capital expenditure that may be needed that would result

In Topic 1 of Unit 3, you learned of three (3) ways you can

In Topic 1 of Unit 3, you learned of three (3) ways you can convince the hiring authority to buy what you have to offer. Yourself and your personality Your abilities and your credentials Your potential worth to the company For this discussion, reflect on how you can use yourself

After presenting your capstone Power Point on CAUTI write a

After presenting your capstone Power Point on CAUTI write a 250-350 word summary of the presentation. Include a description of the feedback and questions from your audience after your presentation, and how this interprofessional collaboration and experience will affect your professional practice in the future solid academic writing is expected,

HIM2588 Data Steward Presentation

Imagine that you are a Data Steward and your employer has asked you to teach others in the organization about your role and responsibilities. Prepare a PowerPoint slideshow that describes the role and various responsibilities of a Data Steward. Your presentation should be a minimum of 8 slides (including a

MSN Maternal and Child Health Essay

Health Policy Briefs provide succinct overviews of health policy topics. The intended audience is policymakers, journalists, and others concerned about improving health care in the United States. The briefs explore arguments made on various sides of a policy proposal. They provide guidance on available research behind each perspective. Health policy

Compare and Contrast Definition of Health from Public

Read chapter 1, 2 & 6 of the class textbook and review the attached PowerPoint presentations once done answer the following questions. 1. Compare and contrast definitions of health from a public health nursing perspective. 2. Explain the difference between public/community health nursing practice and community-based nursing practice. 3. Discuss

Health from A Public Health Nursing Perspective Discussion

I need to get done assignment for the subject of health care

I need to get done assignment for the subject of health care analytics and course is Health care managment. Instructions on format and content outline are mentioned in the pdf which is attached below. Content outline needs to be followed properly Word limit: maximum 3000 words Citation style: APA I

FIU Ambiguity and Doubts About Managing ASD Reflection

Autism Spectrum Disorder, Intellectual Disabilities, and Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia After studying Module 5: Lecture Materials & Resources, discuss the following: Reflect on your experience creating a treatment plan for a toddler, school-aged child, or adolescent with autism or an intellectual disability. Describe the clinical situation in detail. (Who was it, when

This assignment requires you to conduct the Strengths (S),

This assignment requires you to conduct the Strengths (S), Weaknesses (W), Opportunities (O), and Threats (T) SWOT Analysis. As the planner for your health organization (selected by you), you will need to prepare a 3-page document addressing your organization’s internal and external environment to include, but not limited to, forces/trends,

EN